Tech is Rigid
One of the things I’ve been thinking about for a while is how digital technology is so rigid. It is rigid in the sense that it is hard to use a piece of digital technology for anything other than what it was intended for. Think about the reverse: an older physical technology like a paper form. I can fill that form out with my pen. Maybe they didn’t leave enough little squares for my last name, no problem, I can just squeeze a few extra letters on to the end. Maybe I don’t know a piece of required information and want to remind myself to come back and fill it in later, just make a small mark to the side of the field - problem solved. Or, if this is an extra-special form that I don’t want to put extraneous marks on, maybe use one of those “sign here” stickies and take it away when I’m done so as to not make of mess of things. I can easily modify the form and augment it with common things around me to serve my purposes.
With digital technology it is very hard to make modifications like this. Take our example of a simple contact form. If the field for the last name is set to only accept a certain number of letters and my legal last name is longer, I’m up a creek. If I don’t have my driver’s license with me and have to go look that up, I can’t mark the field as something I want to come back to.
This is one of the reasons good user experience design is so critical, because if you don’t understand someone’s needs, they will rub against rigid, immovable obstacles. And if the obstacle is big enough, they’re stuck. They just can’t get around it.
On the flip side, this also is where some of the best opportunities come in for designers and creators of digital tech. The magic happens where you add helpful modifications that come from understanding people’s needs so well that you anticipate where the rub will be, where the rigid thing needs to be rounded off just a little. Make it flexible. Make it customizable. Just beware that this can be overdone. Hone in on the most important needs and create the ability for someone to be in control in those areas, leaving the rest rigid and inflexible. Dan Brown in Design Discovery reminds us that when working on design discovery look for artifacts of things outside of the existing systems which point to areas of need – maybe a post-it note, or the need to copy from one place and then paste into another.
We humans are inventive and adaptable. Digital tech is often magic, but suffers from inherent rigidity. It’s our job to inject flexibility into it and make it more human rather than asking our users to become more machine-like.